What’s up with Up?
Cats: Uncategorized, culture|By scanning the reviews, I knew the flick Up would be good, but I must say it came as a surprise when the story of this grieving old man and his plumb eight-year old sidekick found its way into the heart of this crusty typist.
Let’s just say tissues were needed in the same way that tissues are needed whenever I open Robert Munsch’s book Love You Forever.
I’m generally not an easy-sell with these things. I find cheap sentimentality to be lazy, tiresome and cliche. And this makes me angry, especially when I spend good money and time on it. Up managed to move without resorting to eash schmaltz.
It opens with a sweet montage covering of the life of 78-year old Carl Fredrickson (Ed Asner). We meet him as a child, learn of his fascination with aviation and we meet his sweetheart Ellie who shares a dream to go to Paradise Falls in South America. The rest is comes as a snapshot view of their lives together.
Next time we meet Carl he is an old man grieving the loss of his wife Ellie, the loss of his old neighbourhood and the loss of his dream to go to Paradise Falls. So much loss. That’s when Boy Scout Russell appears at the door asking if he can provide an old person assistance so he can earn his “help an old person badge.”
Though a series events, the pair set out on an adventure to Paradise Falls, travelling in the man’s house which is lifted into flight by thousands of helium-filled balloons. Picture perfect.
It’s a whimsical tale, rendered in a colourful, artistic animation that puts you in the mind of a circus or a fair (back in the days when they weren’t full of slimeballs.) There’s adventure, suspense and villainy (voiced exquisitely by Christopher Plummer). There’s goofy humour in the gorky rare bird called Kevin and the dumb dog who appear along the way and help them though their adventures. All of this would be enjoyable on its own.
But it was the bitter-sweet observations on the old man’s compromises that moved me, the stinging regret and sorrow that he never pursued the dream to go to Paradise Falls. They saved money for the trip but something always got in the way: the car, house repairs, life.
How many of us can relate to that?
The old man confronts his regrets each time he opens the My Adventures scrapbook kept by his wife. But he can never turn the page and look at the chapter entitled “Stuff I’m going to do”. Carl can’t face his wife’s regret and lost dreams.
The moment of redemption occurs for Carl when he finally gets up the courage to turn that page. I’ll won’t spoil it here, but this moment is one of the most poignant, beautiful and tear-inducing of any moment in any animation flick, or non-animated flick, for that matter.
I could hear sniffles all around in this film and laughter, and at the end, that rare thing in a movie cinema: applause.
I don’t often hear that.
But then I don’t often leave an animated film – or any film, for that matter – feeling so moved and satisfied by the sheer joy of the story.

June 8th, 2009 at 12:24 pm
I’ve been hearing good things about Up and this pretty much clinches it – I need to go see this, and I shall bring my hanky.
June 8th, 2009 at 2:11 pm
Just reading this review is making me tear up again. I wept like a baby at this movie…more than once. That montage at the beginning was so beautifully done and yes, when Carl finally looks in the back of Ellie’s adventure book, the floodgates really opened for EVERYONE in the theater I saw it in. Our crowd, too, gave the movie hearty applause.
Something that also got a huge reaction from me was the trailer for Toy Story 3! I actually squealed with delight when it started, but then groaned when I saw that it was still a year away.
June 8th, 2009 at 3:16 pm
I have been hearing glowing reviews about this picture, I hope it comes to a theatre here soon!
June 8th, 2009 at 9:35 pm
Thanks for the great review. I really loved Up and I had the same reaction. I knew that it was going to be quite emotional from the beginning with the beautiful montage that summarized a life together. Great cinematic storytelling whether it’s animated or not.
June 9th, 2009 at 12:32 pm
Alright, alright, you’ve talked me into seeing it.
June 10th, 2009 at 8:47 am
Barbara, go and do a review I’d love to hear what you think
Becks, sweet, applause and sniffles in New York
Allison, you’d like it I think
Chris, welcome to GT. I heard from Randonmind that you went and wondered what you thought. Now I know
Deepti, go.
June 10th, 2009 at 8:47 am
Deepti, welcome back to blog land